Best Thermal Carafe Coffee Makers

7 Best Thermal Carafe Coffee Makers

If you’re in search of a thermal carafe coffee maker that’ll help keep your brewed coffee hot for a long period of time so you can enjoy a warm cup of joe whenever you want, then it’s in your best interest that you stick around until the end of this article as we’re about to cover our top picks for the title of the best thermal carafe coffee maker on the market today.

Thermal Carafe vs Glass Carafe

While both thermal and glass carafes have their own pros and cons, the pros definitely outweigh the cons in the case of thermal carafes. Here’s everything you need to know about both types:

Thermal Carafes

Thermal carafes are double-walled containers that feature a vacuum in between their walls. This vacuum is responsible for reducing the effects of convection heat transfer, which helps conserve the temperature of the fluid within the carafe. The double walls on most thermal carafes are built from stainless steel or plastic, but there are models that incorporate different materials as well.

Not only do thermal carafes reduce the effect of convection, but they also minimize the effect of heat transfer through conduction since the two layers are barely in contact with one another. As a result, the fluid within these containers maintains its temperature for a long period of time. The use of a thermal carafe coffee maker will spare you the need to use trays to keep the coffee hot.

Positives

  • Maintains heat and freshness for a considerably long period of time
  • Using a thermal carafe will spare you the taste of burnt coffee beans
  • Thermal carafes are built ruggedly and have high shatter resistance
  • The process of oxidization doesn’t occur quickly with thermal carafes
  • Thermal carafes boast a modern look that a lot of people are fond of

Negatives

  • The busier construction of thermal carafes makes them pretty heavy
  • Thermal carafes tend to be a lot more expensive than glass carafes
  • Unless noted, most thermal carafes are not dishwasher-compatible

Glass Carafes

Glass carafes are much simpler in terms of construction than thermal carafes, as they’re exactly what they sound like, glass pots. In order to keep the fluids warm, glass carafes require to sit on top of a hotplate, which is something that thermal carafes don’t require. However, the traditional design of most glass carafes grants them an elegant look that’s perfect for formal occasions.

Positives

  • Glass carafes come at more affordable price tags than thermal carafes
  • This type is ideal for formal presentation thanks to its traditional design
  • Glass carafes tend to be dishwasher-safe, making them easier to clean

Negatives

  • Unlike in thermal carafes, coffee can get pretty rancid in a glass carafe
  • Glass carafes require the use of hotplates to maintain fluid temperature
  • Due to their glass construction, glass carafes tend to be easier to break

Thermal Carafe Coffee Maker Buying Guide

Due to the wide variety of thermal carafe coffee makers on the market, trying to identify the ideal unit can be quite overwhelming, especially when you take into consideration the array of varying features that each unit has to offer. Taking the following factors into consideration will help make your selection process easier and more streamlined.

Capacity

When shopping for a thermal carafe coffee maker, you’ll need to consider the number of people that will be craving a cup of joe every morning. Fortunately, carafes coffee makers are available in a wide range of capacities, from less than a handful to up to a dozen cups of coffee. However, you should keep in mind that larger coffee makers will require more kitchen counter space.

If you’re opting to get a larger thermal carafe coffee maker, then you want to make sure that it’s equipped with a brew-pause function. The reason why is because larger coffee makers require more time to brew the coffee than smaller models, which isn’t convenient when you’re in a rush to get to work. The brew-pause function allows you to snatch a cup of coffee mid-cycle.

Durability

The last thing you want happening to your coffee maker after you’ve invested a pretty penny on it is to be rendered useless after taking a beating or two. The most durable thermal carafes tend to be built from stainless steel. However, stainless steel thermal carafes tend to be quite heavier than their plastic or glass counterparts, so make sure that weight won’t be an issue.

Controls

Thermal carafe coffee makers are available in manual and programmable models, with various different features such as dials, buttons, touchpads, and LCDs. These features are just different means of controlling the machine and its brew timer, and your objective is to choose the type of functionality that’s more convenient for you.

Brewing

When inspecting the brewing capabilities of a certain thermal carafe coffee maker, your primary concerns should be the brewing time and brewing temperature. The former doesn’t really need that much explanation. Simply, some units take longer than others to brew the coffee, so based on how fast you want your coffee to be made, your decision should be made in accordance.

As far as temperature, this is what you need to pay extra attention to because the taste of your coffee has a lot to do with the brewing temperature. Ideally, the brewing temperature should be somewhere between 195 and 205 °F, so you need to make sure that the thermal carafe coffee maker that you buy is capable of reaching and maintaining this temperature range.

Portability

We’ve already touched a little bit on how stainless steel thermal carafe coffee makers tend to be heavier than their counterparts, which isn’t really convenient if you plan on moving your machine around often. In this case, you want to make sure you get a smaller unit or one that’s made from a different material than stainless steel to ensure that it can be carried around with ease.

Additions

  • Automatic Shut-Off – We strongly suggest buying a coffee maker that boasts automatic shut-off because such units can help save a lot of energy. Also, you won’t really need to keep an eye on the machine while it’s working as it’ll shut itself off.
  • Built-In Grinder – There are coffee makers that feature built-in grinders for people who aren’t quite fond of using a separate grinder to grind their coffee beans. However, such units don’t allow you to control the grinding zone and they tend to be harder to clean.
  • Sound or Light Alerts – There are units on the market that will let you know as soon as the brewing cycle is complete with the aid of sound or light alerts, which comes in handy for when you have your hands full with whatever task while the machine is brewing.

Cuisinart CPO-850 Pour-Over Coffee Brewer

Equipped with two coffee-bar brewers, the Cuisinart CPO-850 offers a flavor that’s equivalent to that of a coffee bar. Thanks to its remarkable ability to extract flavor, this pour-over machine has won the SCAA Home Brewer Certification, which is why it’s ranked so high on our list. Using the Cuisinart CPO-850, you can brew premium coffee with little to no effort whatsoever.

The CPO-850 does a wonderful job providing the bloomer flavor that coffee fiends fall head over heels for. The way it does that is by pre-wetting its grounds before the brewing operation begins. This brilliant piece of machinery offers you the ability to enjoy your coffee the way you like using strength and temperature control features that are extremely easy to adjust.

This coffee brewer is also equipped with a laser-etched filter that’s built from stainless steel. Not only that, but it also features a charcoal water filter. Both filters work in unison to provide you an exceptional cup of coffee on demand. As far as the unit’s capacity, it can brew 64-ounces worth of coffee, which equates to about 8 cups of coffee in one cycle.

It’s worth noting that the Cuisinart CPO is available in a glass-carafe version (CPO-800), which is designed for coffee lovers that aren’t concerned with keeping the coffee hot for a long time. In terms of construction, the CPO-850 boasts a remarkably-rugged construction, so you don’t have to worry about it giving up on you after a few beatings. This thing is built like a tank!

The Cuisinart CPO-850 grants you the ability to choose the brewing temperature between extra hot and hot. Moreover, you can choose the brew strength between mild, medium, and bold. The CPO-850 also features the brew-pause function that allows you to pour a nice cup of joe without having to wait for the cycle to be completed. Overall, a quality machine that offers quality flavor.

Pros

  • Meets the thorough technical requirements of the SCAA
  • Features a sleek design and highly-durable construction
  • Offers users alterable brewing temperature and strength
  • Equipped with handy 24-hour programmable technology
  • Provides up to 8 cups of gourmet coffee in a single cycle

Cons

  • The LCD display on this machine tends to dim over time
  • Various customers have pointed out occasional leakage

Black+Decker CM2035B Thermal Coffee Maker

The CM2035B Thermal Coffee Maker from Black+Decker is a high-capacity unit that can deliver 12 cups of coffee in one cycle. It features a vacuum-sealed, double-walled carafe that built from stainless steel to withstand the test of time and preserve the temperature of your coffee for long periods of time. With the CM2035B, you can say so long to the taste of stale and rancid coffee.

The CM2035B offers you the ability to adjust the brew strength of your coffee to your liking. And if you’re someone that prefers a bolder flavor, you’ll definitely appreciate the ‘strong’ option. The machine is also equipped with the Evenstream Showerhead which delivers an evenly-dispersed flow of water that runs through the packed grounds of coffee, providing optimal flavor.

As soon as you look at the Black+Decker CM2035B, you’ll notice that it features a carafe with a wide mouth opening, which may lead you to conclude that this machine drips a lot. However, it’s equipped with a No-Drip Perfect Pour Spout that helps put an end to spills while pouring. As you can see, Black+Decker has thought of everything while designing this machine.

While you don’t need to worry about the thermal carafe getting damaged easily as it’s built from stainless steel, you do need to give it extra care in terms of maintenance. From time to time, it’s recommended that you flush the thermal carafe with a vinegar-water solution in order to remove the rigid water scale that tends to form on the heater so that it functions properly.

The Black+Decker CM2035B is one of the easiest coffee machines to adjust and operate on this list, thanks to the incorporation of quick-touch programming functions. The unit also features the Sneak-A-Cup feature which allows you to stop the flow of coffee whenever you want so that you can get a quick cup of joe without making a mess. Highly recommended!

Pros

  • This machine offers a great deal of value for the buck
  • Can produce up to 12 cups of coffee in just one cycle
  • One of the easiest coffee makers to operate on our list
  • This machine doesn’t suffer from dripping issues at all
  • Allows you to regulate the brew strength of your coffee

Cons

  • Cleaning this bad boy isn’t as easy as we’d like it to be
  • This unit takes a considerable amount of time to brew

Technivorm Moccamaster KBT Coffee Brewer

When it comes to boasting a sleek and modern design, the Technivorm Moccamaster KBT is an absolute eye-catcher. This great-looking coffee maker looks like it came from the future. It’s also built like a tank with its stainless steel construction, so it’s definitely going to last you a long time. And thanks to its modern looks, you’ll find it pretty easy to integrate this brewer in your kitchen.

The KBT Coffee Brewer from Technivorm is equipped with a unique copper-boiling element that heats water in a rapid fashion in order to keep the temperature of the water between 196 ºF and 205 ºF, which is crucial for extracting the coffee soluble. The whole operation is super fast-acting and quiet. You should expect a carafe full of coffee with 4 to 6 minutes from this machine.

This machine is also equipped with a manual-adjust brew basket that offers the user 3 different options that can be selected using a toggle switch. With the aid of these options, you can steep your coffee longer. You can also pull the carafe away as the unit is brewing after you’ve closed the basket. And don’t worry the manual-adjust brew basket doesn’t come with a learning curve.

The Technivorm Moccamaster KBT Coffee Brewer is capable of achieving ideal water saturation time, which grants the coffee a great aroma, flavor, and complexity. This is achieved with the aid of the brew basket’s conical design that helps regulate a steep that takes about 6 minutes. After the brewing process is completed, the copper element will be turned off automatically.

The KBT Coffee Maker is a remarkable machine, but it’s not a very affordable machine. It’s one of the most expensive coffee brewers on our list, which may lead you to opt for another brewer, but hold your horses a second, did you know that this machine is backed by a 5-year warranty? This is something to consider since most units on the market come with a 2-year warranty.

Pros

  • Arguably the most well-built coffee brewer on our list
  • A modern design that’s perfect for nowadays kitchens
  • Delivers a carafe full of coffee within just 4-6 minutes
  • You can snatch a quick cup of coffee during operation
  • The unit is backed by an unmatched 5-year warranty

Cons

  • One of the most expensive coffee brewers on our list
  • It tends to spill due to the lack of a real carafe spout

Hamilton Beach FlexBrew Thermal Coffee Maker

The FlexBrew from Hamilton Beach is one of the most flexible thermal coffee makers on our list. It allows you to customize your cup of coffee based on your needs so that you don’t end up with the same tasting coffee every time. This is highly convenient if you’re going to share your coffee machine with other people with different coffee tastes in your household or workspace.

Whether you’re into K-Cup packs or fresh-ground coffee, the FlexBrew Thermal Coffee Maker is going to deliver exactly that which you like, thanks to its incredible array of features. It features 2 different sides. The carafe side allows you to brew a full pot of coffee using grounds coffee while the single-serve side allows you to make a hot cup of joe using grounds or single-serve packs.

Not only does the FlexBrew offer you 2 different sides, but it’s also equipped with 2 reservoirs of water that you’ll find super easy to fill. The reservoirs feature separate windows that allow you to see the water level inside them so that you know when they require to be filled. You can choose the strength of your coffee on both sides with ease. Your choices are bold or regular.

As far as capacity, the single-serve side of the machine can brew up to 10 ounces of coffee with a single-serve pack. Alternatively, you can use it to fill a mug with 14 ounces of coffee if you use grounds. The carafe side, on the other hand, offers a 10-cup capacity. The stainless steel carafe does a brilliant job when it comes to keeping your coffee warm for a long period of time.

With the Hamilton Beach FlexBrew, you also have the ability to adjust the brewing temperature to your liking. You can choose between hot and extra hot. One of the awesome things about this coffee brewer is that it’s highly energy-efficient, so you don’t have to cut down on coffee in order to ensure a low electrical bill. The FlexBrew allows you to enjoy your coffee whenever you want.

Pros

  • Features 2 different sides offering 2 different tastes
  • The construction of this machine is highly compact
  • Each side has its own perceivable water reservoir
  • Provides control over the strength and temperature
  • The unit is easily-programmable to suit your needs

Cons

  • The single-serve option requires quite a bit of time
  • The single-brew cycle tends to make a lot of noise

Cuisinart CHW-14 Programmable Coffeemaker

Cuisinart makes a stellar second entry on our list with its 12-cup brewer, the CHW-14. This unit offers you the ability to control the strength of your coffee between regular and bold. You’re also allowed to set the brew time up to 24-hours ahead so that you can wake up early in the morning and find your coffee ready to be poured and consumed. Pretty convenient if you’re in a rush!

What’s so awesome about this machine is that it’s not just used to make coffee, you can actually use it to heat water that can be used for making other hot drinks such as tea. Heating water with this machine doesn’t take more than a few seconds too! This machine features a thermal carafe that can keep your coffee hot for a long time and has a drip-free pour spout.

The unit is equipped with a few automatic functions such as the auto-on settings and self-clean function, allowing for ease of use and operation. The CHW-14 offers its users the ability to alter the warming temperature to their liking. The water itself is heated up to 190 ºF before it begins pouring on the grounds coffee, allowing for ideal flavor extraction without a bit of a burnt taste.

To ensure a great flow of water that’s free of impurities that can take away from the taste of the coffee, the Cuisinart CHW-14 utilizes charcoal and gold-tone water filters that help maintain the water’s purity. The unit also features a brew-pause function that allows you to snatch a mug of coffee without the need to wait for the cycle to be completed.

Other features that the CHW-14 boasts include a backlit LCD display that’s easy to read, a light indicator that begins to shimmer when it’s time to decalcify, and a sound alert that chimes when the brewing cycle is completed. The alarm can easily be turned on and off for convenience. All in all, the CHW-14 is another fantastic coffee maker from Cuisinart that’s worth checking out.

Pros

  • Equipped with 2 filters that help keep the water pure
  • This brewer is easy to put together and disassemble
  • Features various automatic functions for ease of use
  • Can remove the drip tray to make way for taller mugs
  • A highly affordable brewer for the value it has to offer

Cons

  • This machine occasionally leaks while you’re pouring
  • The unit tends to make a lot of noise during operation

Mr. Coffee Optimal Brew Thermal Coffeemaker

Mr. Coffee might not be as popular of a brand as names such as Cuisinart, Black+Decker, and Hamilton Beach, but the quality of the coffee that this 10-cup coffee brewer is capable of making is certainly on par with the aforesaid names. And the best thing about this unit is that it comes at a price tag that’s a lot more affordable than most other coffee makers included on this list.

One of the things that makes this coffee brewer stand out is that it’s capable of producing piping hot coffee at temperatures of up to 205 ºF, while other coffee makers tend to linger between 196 ºF and 200 ºF. You might think that an affordable unit like this one is going to compromise on the automatic functions that higher-end units have, but this isn’t the case with the Optimal Brew.

The Mr. Coffee Optimal Brew features the auto-pause option that allows you to grab a cup of joe while the cycle is still running. It’s also worth noting that this brewer from Mr. Coffee is one of the easiest to use and operate. In addition, it features compact and lightweight construction that you will find super easy to move around, which can’t be said about a lot of units on our list.

The unit features a Just-Brew thermal carafe that’s just as great at maintaining the temperature as the carafes equipped with higher-end machines. In addition, this coffee maker can brew at a very high speed and temperature, providing you with coffee-bar quality in a short period of time. The unit also features a timer that allows you to keep track of your coffee’s freshness.

Just like a lot of coffee makers on the market, Mr.Coffee’s Optimal Brew features a self-cleaning function that allows you to clean the entire unit with a single push of a button. It also features an option that allows you to delay the brewing process or pause it completely. There’s also an auto shut off function that turns the unit off after 2 hours of use, in case you forget to do it yourself.

Pros

  • Delivers great value considering its affordable price tag
  • Features a self-cleaning function for your convenience
  • Can brew at high temperatures in a relatively short time
  • The gasket beneath the carafe helps reduce heat loss
  • Features water filters that effectively remove impurities

Cons

  • The unit tends to let out scorching steam from its vents
  • The carafe’s lid tends to spill everywhere once removed

Cuisinart DCC-3750 Elite Thermal Coffeemaker

With its third and final entry, Cuisinart solidifies its status as one of the best manufacturers in the department of coffee brewers. The DCC-3750 is a 10-cup coffee brewer that boasts super sleek construction that’s perfect for modern homes. And while being a highly affordable coffee brewer, this unit combines an array of premium features that offer users top-notch, gourmet quality.

The emergence of the Cuisinart DCC-3750 Elite Thermal Coffeemaker has revolutionized how a cup of coffee is to be made with its Extreme Brew technology. This technology allows the unit to brew almost 25% faster than most of its competitors without subtracting from the quality or taste of the coffee, meaning that your cup of joe will be ready minutes from turning the machine on.

The unit is equipped with a broad range of programmable functions that, when coupled with the option to control the strength of your coffee, help provide you a fully customized cup of coffee. It also features another cool function that the manufacturer calls the Wake-Up function. It’s mainly incorporated in the unit so that users don’t go about their day without their dose of caffeine.

The DCC-3750 features a stainless steel thermal carafe that ensures your coffee remains piping hot for hours so that you don’t have to run a new cycle every 15 minutes because your drink has gone cold. It’s also equipped with the option to adjust the brewing temperature to your liking. For this option, it relies on an internal heating system that offers 3 different temperature settings.

The thermal carafe on this unit features a drip-free spout and a convenient wide grip that allows for ease of handling. The DCC-3750 also boasts fully-automatic touchpad controls that provide a wide range of options that include auto-shutoff and self-cleaning. Moreover, it’s equipped with charcoal and gold-tone water filters to help ensure a cup of a coffee that’s free of impurities.

Pros

  • The Extreme-Brew technology offers fast performance
  • The construction is super attractive and highly durable
  • Offers users control over the temperature and strength
  • Equipped with a couple of filters to ensure water purity
  • The carafe is equipped with a drip-free pouring spout

Cons

  • It’s not easy to verify the water level inside the reservoir
  • Closing the lid completely becomes hard after a while

Final Words

There you have it, 7 of the best thermal carafe coffee makers available today. We’re confident that one of the brewers reviewed in this article is going to meet your needs and budget. We’d love for you to share with us which one of the above-mentioned brewers you think is the best.

Scroll to Top